One post tagged with "cold leads"

🔴 Series Difficulty: ADVANCED (Part 9 of 10) — The most sophisticated workflow in the series. Combines signal detection, research, scoring, and personalized outreach.

Here's a stat that should keep every SDR up at night: 80% of sales require 5+ follow-ups after the initial contact, but 44% of salespeople give up after just one follow-up.

You've lived this. A prospect seemed interested. Maybe they responded to your first email. Maybe they even took a meeting. Then... silence. You sent a follow-up. Nothing. Another follow-up. Crickets. So you moved on to the next lead, and that once-promising prospect became another cold record in your CRM.

But here's the thing: cold leads aren't dead leads. They're leads who weren't ready at the time. Their priorities shifted. Their budget got frozen. Their champion left the company. A competitor swooped in. Whatever the reason, "not now" doesn't mean "not ever."

The SDRs who crush their quota know this. They're not just great at opening new conversations — they're relentless at re-opening old ones. And in Part 9 of our Claude Code + MarketBetter series, we'll show you exactly how to build an AI-powered system that ensures no lead ever truly goes cold.

Why this is the most advanced post in the series: This workflow pulls together nearly everything you've learned. You'll use research skills from Part 2 to understand what's changed with cold leads. Email writing from Part 3 to craft re-engagement messages. Competitive intel from Part 5 to find new angles. Lead scoring from Part 6 to prioritize which cold leads are worth reactivating. And clean CRM data from Part 7 to make sure your records are accurate before you reach out. This is where all the pieces come together — the dress rehearsal before the full playbook in Part 10.

Why Leads Go Cold (And Why That's Okay)​

Understanding why a lead went cold is the first step to bringing them back. Here are the most common reasons:

1. Bad timing — They weren't actively buying when you reached out
2. Changed priorities — An internal project took precedence
3. Budget freeze — End of quarter/year budget cuts
4. Champion left — Your internal advocate changed jobs
5. Competitor won — They went with someone else (this one's not permanent either)
6. Lost in the noise — Your follow-ups got buried and they forgot about you
7. Content gap — You didn't provide enough value to stay top of mind

Notice that most of these are temporary conditions. Budgets get refreshed. New champions emerge. Competitors disappoint. Priorities shift back. The question isn't whether cold leads come back — it's whether you're watching when they do.

MarketBetter's Secret Weapon: Signal Detection for Cold Leads​

This is where MarketBetter changes the game. While most SDRs rely on hope and manual follow-ups, MarketBetter is actively monitoring your website for returning visitors. Including the leads you wrote off months ago.

Here's what MarketBetter's signal detection does for cold leads:

• Return visitor alerts — A prospect who hasn't visited your site in 3 months suddenly shows up on your pricing page. That's a signal.
• Increased engagement — A cold account that used to visit once starts visiting 3-4 times a week. Something changed.
• New stakeholders — Someone else from a cold account starts browsing your site. Maybe a new champion.
• Page-level intent — Not just "they visited" but "they visited your comparison page vs. [Competitor]." That's a very specific signal.

When MarketBetter detects these return signals, it's like getting a second chance — but only if you move fast and move smart.

The Cold Lead Reactivation Framework​

Step 1: Audit Your Cold Leads​

Start by understanding what you're working with:

"I have a list of 50 leads that went cold in the last 3-6 months. For each one, I have: company name, contact name, title, last interaction date, and the stage where they went cold.

Analyze this list and categorize each lead:

1. High reactivation potential — Company is growing, may have new budget, likely still has the original pain point
2. Medium reactivation potential — Worth a touch but don't expect miracles
3. Low reactivation potential — Company situation has changed significantly (downsizing, acquired, etc.)
4. Champion changed jobs — The person left the company. Research where they went (this might be an even better opportunity)

For each high-potential lead, suggest a reactivation angle based on what's likely changed since we last spoke."

This audit takes Claude Code a few minutes and saves you from wasting time on leads that genuinely won't come back.

Step 2: Research What Changed​

For your high-potential cold leads, you need to understand what's different now:

"Research these 15 high-potential cold leads. For each one, tell me what's changed in the last 3-6 months:

1. Company changes — New funding, leadership changes, acquisitions, expansion, layoffs
2. Industry changes — New regulations, market shifts, competitive landscape changes
3. Technology changes — New tools adopted, tech stack changes
4. Personnel changes — Did my contact get promoted? Did new stakeholders join?
5. Public signals — Recent LinkedIn posts, press mentions, job postings

For each lead, give me a 'reactivation angle' — a specific, relevant reason to reach out that doesn't feel like a generic follow-up."

Step 3: Craft Reactivation Messages​

Generic "just checking in" follow-ups don't work. They signal that you have nothing new to offer. Instead, use Claude Code to write value-led reactivation messages:

The "New Development" Re-engagement:

"Write a re-engagement email to [Name] at [Company]. They went cold 3 months ago. Since then, [specific thing that changed at their company]. Connect this change to our solution without being heavy-handed. Don't reference our old conversation. Make it feel like a new, timely touchpoint."

Example output:

Subject: quick thought on the European expansion

Hi Sarah, I noticed Acme just opened the London office — congrats. When US SaaS companies expand into EMEA, one of the tricky parts is maintaining outbound quality in a new market where your brand doesn't have the recognition it does at home.

We've been helping a few companies in a similar stage solve this — essentially getting new-market outbound performing at domestic levels within 60 days instead of 6 months. Thought it might be relevant to what you're building over there.

Worth a conversation?

Notice: no mention of the old conversation, no "just following up," no desperation. It reads like a fresh, relevant outreach based on a current event.

The "Competitor Disappointment" Re-engagement:

"Write a re-engagement email to [Name] at [Company]. They went with [Competitor] 6 months ago. Based on recent G2 reviews, [Competitor]'s customers are reporting [specific issue]. Write a helpful, non-salesy email that addresses this topic without directly suggesting they should switch."

The "New Stakeholder" Re-engagement:

"[Company] went cold 4 months ago. My contact was [Original Name]. MarketBetter shows someone new from the company — possibly [New Name/Title] — visiting our site. Write an email to the new person that introduces our solution fresh, without referencing the old relationship."

The "Value-First" Re-engagement:

"Write a re-engagement email to [Name] that leads with genuine value — an insight, a benchmark, or a relevant trend — with zero sales pitch. The goal is to restart the conversation by being useful. We can sell later. Right now, I just want them to reply."

For more on crafting effective cold emails that get replies, see Part 3 of this series and our standalone guide on how to write cold emails.

Building Multi-Touch Reactivation Sequences​

One email won't reactivate a cold lead. You need a sequence. Here's a proven 5-touch reactivation cadence:

Touch 1 (Day 1) — The Value Lead: Email with a relevant insight, benchmark, or trend. No pitch. Just value.

Touch 2 (Day 3) — The LinkedIn Engage: Like or comment on their recent LinkedIn post. Not a sales comment — a genuine, thoughtful reaction. (Use Claude Code to draft the comment based on their post content.)

Touch 3 (Day 5) — The Resource Share: Share a relevant blog post, case study, or industry report via email. Position it as "thought you'd find this interesting" not "look at our product."

Touch 4 (Day 8) — The Direct Ask: A short, direct email: "I think we could help with [specific challenge]. Worth 15 minutes?"

Touch 5 (Day 12) — The Breakup Email: "I don't want to keep cluttering your inbox. If [specific pain point] isn't a priority right now, totally get it. If it ever becomes one, I'm here."

Use Claude Code to write the entire sequence at once:

"Write a 5-touch reactivation email sequence for [Name] at [Company]. They went cold [X months] ago because [reason if known]. Here's what's changed since then: [new developments].

Sequence:

• Email 1 (Day 1): Value-led, no pitch
• Email 2 (Day 5): Share a relevant resource
• Email 3 (Day 8): Direct but low-pressure ask
• Email 4 (Day 12): Breakup email

Also draft a LinkedIn comment I can leave on one of their recent posts between emails 1 and 2.

Rules: Under 80 words per email. Conversational. No 'just checking in.' Each email should stand alone — they might only see one."

Load this sequence into MarketBetter for automated delivery with smart send timing.

Signal-Triggered Reactivation (The Killer Feature)​

The most powerful reactivation strategy isn't on a schedule — it's signal-triggered. Here's how to set it up:

The Signal → Research → Reach Out Loop​

1. MarketBetter detects a signal: Cold lead returns to your website
2. You research immediately: Ask Claude Code what's changed since they went cold
3. You reach out within the hour: Strike while the signal is hot

"I just got a MarketBetter alert that [Name] from [Company] — a lead that went cold 4 months ago — visited our pricing page and our [feature] page today. Research what's happened at their company since [last interaction date] and draft an immediate outreach email. This needs to feel timely but not stalkerish — don't mention the website visit directly. Use a recent company development as the reason for reaching out."

Why speed matters: When a cold lead returns to your site, there's a window. They're actively thinking about a solution. They might be evaluating you and 2 competitors. The first SDR to reach out with a relevant message has a massive advantage.

Automating Signal Response with MarketBetter​

You don't have to manually watch for return signals all day. MarketBetter can be configured to:

• Send you instant alerts when cold leads return to your website
• Trigger automated sequences based on specific page visits
• Flag return visitors in your daily playbook for immediate action
• Show you the full visit history so you can tailor your approach

For more on signal-based selling and how to act on intent signals, read our signal-based selling guide.

Analyzing Your Cold Lead Pipeline​

Use Claude Code to understand patterns in your cold leads:

"Here's a list of 100 leads that went cold in the last 6 months, including: company, contact, title, when they entered the pipeline, when they went cold, the stage where they stalled, and the reason (if known).

Analyze this data and tell me:

1. Where do leads most commonly go cold? (After first meeting? After proposal? After demo?)
2. When do they go cold? (Time of year, number of days after first contact)
3. Who goes cold? (Certain titles, company sizes, industries more than others)
4. Why do they go cold? (Common reasons if documented)
5. What patterns suggest they'll come back vs. stay cold?
6. Based on these patterns, what should I change about my process to prevent leads from going cold in the first place?"

This analysis often reveals systemic issues. Maybe your follow-up timing is off. Maybe you're losing deals at a specific stage. Maybe certain ICPs just don't convert for you. These insights improve your entire pipeline, not just your reactivation efforts.

The "Champion Changed Jobs" Play​

When your contact leaves the company, most SDRs see it as a loss. Smart SDRs see it as two opportunities:

1. New company opportunity: Your champion knows your product. They might bring it to their new company.
2. Old company opportunity: Someone new took over their role. They might be reevaluating vendors.

"My contact [Name] just left [Old Company] and joined [New Company] as [New Title]. Research:

1. Does [New Company] fit our ICP? (Size, industry, likely needs)
2. Is [Name]'s new role relevant to our product?
3. What is [New Company] currently using for [our category]?
4. Draft a congratulatory email to [Name] that naturally opens a conversation about their new role's needs

Also research who replaced [Name] at [Old Company] and draft an introductory email to them."

This is one of the highest-converting plays in sales. A champion at a new company is essentially a warm lead at a cold account.

Measuring Reactivation Success​

Track these metrics monthly:

• Reactivation rate: % of cold leads that re-engage after your outreach
• Signal-triggered vs. scheduled: Which reactivation method produces more meetings?
• Time to reactivation: How long after going cold do leads typically come back?
• Reactivation-to-pipeline: % of reactivated leads that become active opportunities
• Revenue from reactivated leads: The ultimate metric

Most SDRs find that reactivated leads convert at a higher rate than brand-new cold leads, because there's already some familiarity and trust. The prospect already knows who you are. You're not starting from zero.

Try This Today​

Here's your concrete action item:

1. Pull 10 leads that went cold in the last 3-6 months
2. Feed them to Claude Code with the audit prompt from Step 1
3. Pick the top 3 with highest reactivation potential
4. Research what's changed for each one (Step 2 prompt)
5. Write one reactivation email for each using the "New Development" approach
6. Send them through MarketBetter with a 3-touch follow-up sequence attached

If even one of those three replies, you've just generated pipeline from something you'd otherwise written off. And you did it in less than 30 minutes.

---

This is Part 9 (🔴 Advanced) of our 10-part series. Final post: Part 10: The Complete AI SDR Playbook — Putting It All Together →

MarketBetter detects when cold leads come back to life. Don't miss the signal. Book a demo to see return visitor alerts in action.